Sunday, January 28, 2007
Berea the difficult
I thought the Third Quarter has been quite a tough one academically. I thought that it was one super quarter that ushered in a host of academic activities like the concert... and the other concerts. I thought that it was one difficult quarter that was made even more difficult by the topics that should've needed continuity but was denied with one given the series of breaks that figured as holidays or rehearsals. Comparative Anatomy needed continuity. Inorganic Chemistry's logic is sequential. Deny both the momentum that each needed to push the facts across and you get gaps in learning.
To my mind, such is the state of the Third Quarter. But there's not much that can be undone now. But having thus described the Third Quarter as one difficult quarter, I also thought that my students are not left without munition to help themselves out of the bind. A difficult task is made easy by summoning extra effort to stave off unnecessary academic distress.
So what do I make of the Third Quarter?
The Third quarter is one moment in time when we learn our lessons the hard way. If in failing we learn to hope for triumph then let failing be so. If in failing we learn to pick up the pieces of a squandered opportunity and learn to move forward, then let failing be so.
But while at this, let it be known that I still hold on to the quote from Plato I gave during that lecture on Friday, "The greatness of a teacher is best measured by the quality of his students."
My hope is that, like the oyster, you be able to make this academic irritant into an academic pearl. An academic pearl that will become the mark of quality students that you are. Then I can sit back with the thought that I have reaped from your struggle, my own struggle for that fruition of an earthly crown - the opportunity to touch as many lives as my own life can.
Saturday, January 27, 2007
Academic Difficulties
.jpg)
There is one very familiar quip coming from my students that I don't get to miss hearing before every exams... "Sir mahirap ba yong test?" Of course I have a ready reply to questions like this. I tell the unsuspecting student that the degree of difficulty of the test is directly related to the level of effort exerted in preparing for it. But going by the same logic, the surest way therefore to gauge the difficulty of a test (relative to the student) is to check at the end of the test whether the student failed or not. This of course does not give reliable results most of the time, hence the fallacy of the claim.
Students this time around (a week after the exams week) are perhaps doubly wary or panicky of uncertain prospects about their performance for the quarter. The week that was and the coming week will take on a mystified animation. Is the mark under the tree (three)? At Berea, a good marking performance stops counting at three. Already, tears have welled from the eyes that have just stayed the night out during the exams... But the quarterly gradings can no longer be undone... Hopes are now anchored on the prospect of getting a mark under the tree (three).
I asked my students... "What do you make of the Third Quarter?" Then a litany of self-deprecating but remorseful recollections and explications germinated out of gloom's horizon. I understand... There's much to be done in the final quarter. And the life of the brain must be nourished still...
| | ||||||
| | | |||||
| | | |||||
Friday, January 19, 2007
A Compendium Cum Evaluation On "Pragmatism and Education by Gerald Gutek"
Gutek, in his article, "Pragmatism and Education", provided a historical and scientific background to the flourishing of the Pragmatist perspective on education. He recognized that John Dewey's Pragmatism grew as an offshoot to Rousseau's Naturalism and Spencer's Social Darwinism. But along the way, Dewey's Pragmatist perspective evolved to achieve refinement with the incorporation into its system of Mead's experimental learning and advocacy of the Pragmatist view that learning has to be "directed toward social reforms".
Gutek offered that Pragmatism was a philosophical expression of America's "frontier experience" that provided for a re-qualification of success based on the repercussions that come as a result of their attempt to transform their different environments for varied human purposes. He stated that Pragmatism came into the picture at a time when Science has quantum-leaped the ushering in of a "technological society" that will become the defining force of the Twentieth Century.
Gutek's examination of Pragmatism centralizes on Dewey's Experimentalism or Instrumentalism. He submits that Dewey's approach to philosophy appropriates the employment of the Scientific Method. Consistent to this method are the identification of a problem or the recognition of a problematic situation, its definition and clarification, construction of a tentative hypothesis, and the actual experimentation process. Such clearly defined steps according to Dewey, approximates the occurrence in the individual of a genuine thought.
With science and its methodology knitted closely into the fabric of the Pragmatist perspective, gradual if not outright rejection of metaphysical absolutes and the "Doctrine of no change", became of paramount concern to the evolution of Pragmatism. Idealism was alternately complemented and supplanted with breakthrough ideas from the sciences. Gutek noted that coinciding with the birth of Dewey is the publication of Darwin's "On the Origin of Species by Natural Selection". Darwin's scientific influence on Dewey can hardly be underestimated. Darwin's thesis on evolution stipulates that populations go through gradual change through time depending upon what becomes of their interaction with their environment.
The influence of evolutionary science to Dewey's Pragmatist perspective according to Gutek is best defined by considering the application of evolutionary principles to social situations. Here is when he noted Herbert Spencer's "Social Darwinism" which stipulates that "competition is a natural order of life".
Both Biological and Social Darwinism influenced Dewey in morphing out his Pragmatist perspective. Dewey believed that human beings, (more than the Rousseauean doctrine of becoming one with nature, or Spencer's fierce struggle with nature for survival), have to utilize nature to promote their advancement and welfare.
Dewey's Theory of Valuation sums it all. This theory is his attempt at unifying "aims, means, and ends". The premise here is that, one has to be accommodating of a broad spectrum of ideas that come from the individual's interaction with other individuals and with nature. On account of which, man accords himself with the means with which he places himself in a better position to make the most out of the interaction.
Implications For Education
In this section, Gutek outlined certain aspects of Dewey's educational philosophy ranging from the conservative and reconstructive processes of Experimentalist education to the forming of a democratic setting for education with the end-in-view of beefing up the curriculum to meet desirable educative outcomes.
Gutek noted that in Dewey's Democracy and Education, the learner is a legitimate participant within a cultural setting. his education comes from a conscious perception of nature without any reference to Idealist antecedents of truth. To learn from a pragmatist viewpoint therefore, is to understand nature through experience by the sensory organs.
Dewey's conservative and reconstructive concept of education posits that transmission of heritage has to proceed in the context of "cultural continuity". Within the society, Dewey claims that a learner can make use of the instrumentalities inherent to the group for the bifurcated purpose of liberating himself and defining his setting.
Education is recognized by Dewey as the "transmitter of the cultural heritage". Implicit to this, he claimed that a learner has to actively engage himself in the dynamism of a structured society - not necessarily to be imposed with strictures willed by the majority in the group and in the process lose his identity as in the Rousseauean sense, or to be locked in Spencerian struggle for social survival, but to be elemental in its definition, interactive in making it a better place to live in, and conscious of the available resources at his disposal that will be instrumental to his liberation.
Evaluation
The Pragmatist perspective is, to a large extent, an American philosophy whose system dates back to Greek thinking. Its widespread practice metamorphosed the entire system of Pragmatism into a multifaceted viewpoint subscribed to by proponents that are equally diverse in their regard of the Pragmatist perspective. Some think of it as a system of realistic idealism, others as a case of idealistic realism. Either way, adherents to this philosophy are one in saying that Pragmatism is but a new way of looking at old ideas in an effort to "do justice" to a broad spectrum of human experience.
The pragmatist is primarily concerned with the activity of knowing through the employment of the methods of science and the relationship of ideas to action. He claims that human beings can only be clear-headed about their ideas if and when the same ideas entail consequences that are material to him and are of certain practical purpose in the achievement of his "being".
Educationally, the methods of reflective thinking are fundamental to Pragmatism. Such methods provide for a framework in which reflection is complemented by action, or ideas being translated into practice.Others prefer to call it praxis which takes on the compromise between reflection (verbalism) and action (activism).
The Pragmatist perspective attempts to inculcate in the learner the judgments (and the parameters with which such judgments were arrived at) that men made to define the society (and the cultural heritage that was germinated from it) of which he is a part. This society is presumed to have promoted that interest and welfare of the members who are active participants.
Thus, in Dewey's Democracy and Education, Pragmatism placed emphases on the need for the learner to be able to solve problems that will be helpful to him. Moreover, ideas derived from the Experimentalist education has to cater to a certain social role that is receptive of social wants. And as society changes, the learner must keep himself apace with new developments by learning to be adaptive and interactive. There hardly is any fault to be found here given the conditions with which the Pragmatist perspective evolved and diversified.
It is therefore a matter of personal conviction to note how current educational systems have coped so well having subscribed to the Experimentalist framework of education.
Tuesday, January 16, 2007
A Compendium Cum Evaluation On "Naturalism and Education by Gerald Gutek"
Gutek's article on Naturalism and Education began with a definition of Naturalism and an enumeration of the leading proponents of the Naturalist philosophy that included the likes of Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Johann Heinrich Pestalozzi, and Herbert Spencer.
Naturalism according to Gutek is adherent to a single natural and physical principle, "which is matter in motion". This single principle is recognized by him as the tie that binds the many Naturalists who hold as many Naturalist views ranging from Rouseau's Romanticist perspective of human nature to Herbert Spencer's Darwinian Evolutionary view that holds that ethical systems are highly competitive.
Gutek recognized that nature and everything that is natural are fundamental to the Naturalist educational theory. As nature asserts its influence to complement human nature, education evolves slowly and very gradually to approximate the equally slow and gradual process of a child's development. For this reason, Gutek maintains that consistent to the educative ideals of naturalism , education has to be unhurried.
Another common belief in Naturalism is that, one has to make use of his senses to comprehend the workings of nature. Comprehension in this sense recognizes that the mind has its own way of unraveling truths about things, and that knowledge of them is based upon the sensations that pass through a sentient organism's sensory organs.
Basically, Rouseau's Naturalist philosophical theses are mirrored in both his The Social Contract and Emile. The Social Contract detailed how the individual lost his identity to the group that accommodated him. The fading or mixing in of the individual to the group is figured by Rouseau as caused by the sheer influence of the will of the many upon the will of one. In the end, the pressure is unilaterally directed upon the individual for him to succumb to the general will and be identified as belonging to the group.
In Emile, Rouseau illustrated his Naturalist/Romanticist philosophy in the character of a boy who has been raised and educated away from the corrupting influences of urbanity and the sophistications that go with it. Rousseau believed that the experience of a natural education prepared Emile to resist and overcome the distortions to genuine education entailed by being enmeshed in a structured society. Such distortions are what Rousseau termed as "amour propre", or pride with all the appurtenances of control, domination, and other means for "social aggrandizement". Conversely, the natural education that Emile obtained, developed in him what Rousseau called, "amour de soi", or love of oneself, that geared him up to become the genuine person that he is - uncorrupted and innocent.
On account of Rousseau's idea of growth and development being gradual, he postulated that like a child going through stages of maturity, education has to be programmed to meet the specific demands that are required for a specific stage. Such stages of human growth and development are identified by Rousseau as: infancy, childhood, preadolescence, adolescence, and young adulthood. Through the second stage, henceforth, Emile is introduced to and taught with the concept of "negative education". Here, Emile is sanitized of the influences of society. Proscriptions preventive of naturalist deviations are imposed upon him and a tracked up Naturalist orientation is inculcated into the young mind.
Implications for Education
Gutek's recognition of Naturalism's implications for education is gleaned from his identification of six Naturalist themes: nature and the natural; Naturalist epistemology; axiology and values; human growth and development from a Naturalist perspective; a Naturalist view of the curriculum; and the teacher-learner relationship in the Naturalist context.
He maintains that nature and the "natural" are key elements in the Naturalist perspective of education. As the terms suggest, the Naturalist is more inclined to submit that a learner is better off educated from the artificialities of society. The premise here being that society imposes unnecessarily, certain corrupting influences upon the individual. the genuineness of the individual's "person" is adulterated with the pressure to make himself fit in and belong to a group with which he can find a common and shared interest. To this end, Naturalism stipulates that leaving the child in his primitive and original state influenced only by sheer motives resulting from the learner's "unspoiled instincts", equips him with unselfish and enlightened understanding of nature as a living source of human growth and development.
On the Naturalist epistemology, Gutek stipulates that though Naturalism did not depart much from the Aristotelian Natural Realism on the basis of their shared scientific realist perspective, it however deviated from the Greek educative methodology of verbalism which was the preferred mode in the latter period of antiquity. Naturalism espoused the "doctrine that we learn through our senses". Implicit to this, is the progressivist claim that a learner learns first-hand if he or she immerses in and with nature and find for him or herself out the intricacies of nature's workings. For this, the Naturalists agree with the Progressivists in promoting sensory experience through means like "field-trips and excursions".
Another common belief in Naturalism as identified by Gutek zeroes in on the Naturalist perspective of axiology, values, and human nature. The Naturalist recognizes that there are two forms of self-esteem: the "amour de soi" and the "amour propre", which take on the natural and social dimensions, respectively. For Rousseau, the natural person or the "noble savage" is good and harbors no inherent evil in his heart. It is on this account that Rousseauean education has to be re-programmed in such a way that desensitization of the child is reduced. Consistent with this, is the concept of negative education. This kind of education employs both prescription and proscription as deemed necessary in the negation of artificialities and contrivances formulated from civilized societies. Such artificialities and contrivances according to Rousseau are counter-productive to the growth and development of the child.
As human growth and development proceed through stages that are cumulative, Naturalists argue that genuine education is and should be situated in accordance with the identified level of preparedness of the individual. Hence, the curriculum has to be devised in such a way that it becomes responsive and receptive to the "being" of the learner.
Evaluation
Naturalism in the Rousseauean sense purports that the learner can genuinely approach the realization of his "being" through an educative process that is detached significantly from the artificialities of a structured society. And as the child perfects his education in a natural setting. Rousseau make out of him a natural person who has developed "amour de soi" that enables him to ward off and overcome the corrupting influence of society.
These Naturalist assertions are practical in a sense that they are rendered operational in a material {natural} setting. But then, whether they are practicable in the context of current educational structures leaves ample room for doubt. Considering the trend with which education, the world over, is rationalized based on Dewey's Pragmatist philosophical perspective, it will be a case of high improbability to turn back the hands of time and pit off anticipated presupposed outcomes against experimentally warranted educative outcomes that the current educational situation has put in place. To this end, it is logical to ask whether infusion of resources into experiments on the naturalist perspective is worth it all. In the Philippine setting, the closest perhaps that can be ascribed with the Naturalist perspective of education is the system that serves as the basis for the establishment of the Philippine High School for the Arts (PHSA). Students who qualify for scholarship at the PHSA are those who are inherently endowed with skills and acumen that are geared towards the arts. The curriculum therefore is redesigned to suit the aesthetic needs and inclinations of the students. On top of this, the school is situated in the pristine environs of Mt. Makiling. More than the complementary relationship between nature and nurture though, no other naturalist tenet may be ascertained as associational to the PHSA system.
The evolution of societies from the period of antiquity to societies that are the inventions of our current collective civilizations has, but proceeded in a linearly progressive manner. Implicit to this, the human experience within a structured society has but progressed from primitive to advanced, technologically. Technology must be understood as a contrivance in itself that is reflective of the evolution through which the mind leapt within the confines of a social structure. Having said this, is there not a Naturalist perspective that relaxes the inflexibility of attributing to society all the evils and none of the good?
William Golding, in his novel, "Lord of the Flies" has this to warn us about. That apart from civilization, man has the tendency to revert back to his atavistic instincts. But then again, perhaps not.
Monday, January 15, 2007
A Compendium Cum Evaluation On "Existentialism and Education by Gerald Gutek"

Summary
Gerald Gutek in his article titled, "Existentialism and Education", indirectly hinted that the Existentialist philosophical perspective is relatively new in a sense that it's influence is yet to take its toll and on account of the premise that it was only after the Second World War that its reach and impact flourished in Europe and elsewhere.
Gutek recognized that Existentialism is not a boxed up 'system of thought". It is according to him, more of an inclination labeled as such in an attempt at convenience to ascribe a nomenclature to a range of "differing revolts against Traditional Philosophy".
Gutek, in this article, presented two of the pioneering and more renowned Existentialist philosophers: Soren Kierkegaard, a Christian, and Jean-Paul Sartre, an atheist.
Gutek, in his presentation of Kierkegaard and Sartre, provided sufficient background of them to contextualize the Existentialist thoughts that they championed either as a means with which they deconstructed the authoritarian status-quo prevalent during their times or simply as an academic tussle against philosophical Idealism and the "absolutes" that were elemental to it.
On one hand, he characterized Kierkegaard as a free-thinker who refused any and all forms of subjugation to and by the pantheistic inflexibilities of the Danish Lutheran Church of his time. He also noted the commentary Kierkegaard used to counter Hegel's 'Philosophical Idealism". It centralized on the "architectonic philosophical system" purported by Hegel which, according to Kierkegaard, finds realization only in the state. He noted the impersonal and detached tendencies of Christians in the professions of their faith. Here is when Kierkegaard emphasized the term, "leap of faith". An act that engages one into a personal relationship with God on the basis of having the freedom to define one's "being-in-the-world" with meaning that, and as Kierkegaard suggested, will lead to "authenticity".
On the other hand, Gutek introduced Jean-Paul Sartre beginning with a detailed account of the Nazi setting that defined in more ways than one, the shaping of his Existentialist mind-set and extending to the irrationality and savagery of Hitler that rendered senseless any attempt at living life amidst a backdrop of wanton atavism and dehumanizing barbarism. Such are the conditions that Sartre has personally experienced in the prison camp.
With reference to this background, Gutek figures Sartre's Existentialism as embodied in a phrase the latter himself coined, "existence precedes essence". This neologized existential maxim refutes the existing traditional mind-set popularized in the early part of the Twentieth Century that presupposes an antecendent - not in the Aristotelian sense, that directs human nature.
Of particular interest in this article is the characterization with which Gutek painted a vivid portrait of a "lost" generation that saw the crisis of mass society. Such crisis provided for a fertile philosophical landscape that invited man to re-examine his Existential purpose and relationship of such purpose to existence and essence.
Here, he noted how humans became a mere extension of machines. Gutek cited for instance the factory workers who worked alongside contrivances or gadgets that did most of the work and that needed very little complementary assistance from the human workforce. Assembly lines were built to jack up the mass production of goods. Hardly has man (the masses) coped with the technological advancement characteristic of the time defined by a world at war.
Educationally, Existentialism is critical of the systematically standardized and neatly packaged curriculums that are targeted at students, invariably classified according to age, academic preparation, and scholastic orientation. Existentialism in this regard purports the reduction of "impersonalization that has affected schooling", and the introduction of the "I-Thou" relationship between the mentor and the learner. Gutek also noted the "rejection of systems" in the Existentialist perspective. Needless to say, Existentialism has practically detached itself to any traditional philosophical belief-systems. This however, is just half of the Existentialist equation. The other half enmeshes an attack on Pragmatism's employment of the scientific method through experimentalism. The Existentialist sees in this situation the individual being"overwhelmed" in his/her interaction with "like-minded" persons that forces him/her to decide, mindful of the collective will of the group.
Implications For Education
On Existentialism's implications for education, Gutek took on the US educational tradition. Here, he emphasized the public school conception that is supposed to be receptive and accommodative of the diversity characteristic of the American Society. It is on account of this premise that a need for an institutionalization of cultural pluralism is recognized.
But Gutek noted that the Existentialist perspective is critical of the group-oriented mode of learning based on Dewey's Pragmatist Experimentalism.
Existentialism posits that mentors have to be very wary about infringing too much into the educative hemispheres of the learner. Gutek maintains that the "I-Thou" relationship still serves as ground upon which Existential philosophizing in education is anchored.
Educationally, Existentialism holds that the school, being one that is situated in the material world has to provide a realistic atmosphere that invites optimization of the learner's potential to make choices that help him/her achieve authenticity in the context of individuality. But such an atmosphere has to equally provide situations where recognition of consequences comes in tandem with the Existential pursuit for freedom within the educative framework.
Evaluation
Existentialism is a mind-set that accords premium to man's freedom to make choices that he deems instrumental in his pursuit for authenticity. For this, Existentialism provided a perspective that is alternative to Hegel's Idealism that heralded the virtues of absolute and universalizable truths about the material cosmos. It has to be noted though that authenticity in education is adumbrated with value-creation without reference to any external antecedent. Man is presumed to have the facility to choose from among options that he regards as contributory to the definition of his own person and the unraveling of the essence of his existence. Hence, unlike that of Plato's claim that man is antecendently good until he immerses himself in society, Existentialism following Sartre's claim, is consistent with the making of a man by him and for himself with nothing else to boot but himself and the environment that he is in contact with.
Following Kierkegaard's claim however, a twist gets into the picture with Existentialism being equated to Christianism. A "leap of faith" is what Kierkegaard considered as elemental in the realization of man's Christian life.
Jostein Gaarder, author of Sophie's World, in a chapter on Kierkegaard as told in the same aforementioned book, started with a philosophical inebriation. Sophie was handed over with two bottles, one red and the other blue, by a young girl named Alice. The bottles were very inviting in their labels that read, "Drink me" and "Drink me too". Sophie at first hesitated aas they "might be poisonous". The red bottle altered Sophie's world into one that caused everything to proceed into a grand fusion. This was associational to Hegel's Pantheism or Idealism. The blue bottle is Kierkegaard's virtual world-design for Sophie where everything is and has a world of its own.
Kierkegaard's Existentialist perspective purports a dangerously tempting proposition that puts premium on claims that are hanging loose on thin air like love, forgiveness, and the like. As there exists no measure with which the validity of such claims is gauged, Kierkegaard offered that this very uncertainty adds up to his assertion that claims of this species are more meaningful. "Meaning" in this regard emanates from one's faith in the person making the claim and from one's personal valuation of the claim made. For himj, subjective truth is more important than its objective counterpart. To firm this claim up, he posited that the truth value of the claim that you've been forgiven is more important than the truth value of the geometric claim that the sum of the angles of a triangle is 180 degrees. Here is when Sophie has every reason to be worried about getting poisoned or intoxicated. Unfortunately, for Kierkegaard, he did not live long enough to witness the retrogression of his "leap of faith" down to "leap of extremism". Blind faith yielded to the ubiquity of "holier than thou's" whose minds are devoid of any form of reason other than that which they hold dear in their hearts for warranting them salvation. But that's another story. It is now a matter of conjectural interest to learn how he would have leapt out of faith after September the 11th.
Sartre reasoned from the pulpits of prison. To refute his Existentialist perspective that "existence precedes essence" is historicism to say the least. And while he ran short of advocating "live and let live", does it make the assertion less of a rule of common justice? To this end, Existentialism is better captured by Sartre than by Kierkegaard. But Kierkegaard lived his life happier perhaps. But then again, perhaps not.
Sunday, January 14, 2007
The Place Of Analytic Philosophy Of Education On the Education And Training Of School Teachers
The author, Prof. Evelina M. Orteza, in her article titled, "The Place Of Analytic Philosophy Of Education On The Education And Training Of School Teachers", made an attempt to show the central role and function of Analytic Philosophy in the education and training of school teachers.
Orteza's paper is dichotomized into two parts. The first part provided a commentary on Traditional Philosophy as practiced in education and its implication for certain "significant matters of formal education" like teaching, learning, and the curriculum. The second part provided an argument for the place of Analytic Philosophy of education in teacher preparation programs.
In Orteza's commentary on the Traditional Philosophy of education, she raised several questions illustrative of a framework for abstract considerations that can guide educational practices along one's "accepted Traditional Philosophy of Education". And while she considered imaginable answers to traditional philosophic questions, she argued in this part the speculative nature of such questions and their dubious relation to practical problems.
As such, she queried if at all, these traditional methods of philosophizing could render clarity and order to concepts innate to the whole of the education enterprise. Here is when she offered the the introduction of the Analytic Philosophy of Education as instrumental to the discovery and development of "logical features" of terms independent of a philosophy of education.
Orteza, prior to her building up of a case for the place of Analytic Philosophy of education in the education and training of school teachers, defined "place" as pertaining to role and function, played and operated upon respectively, when dealing with problems appurtenant to education.
Three motivational questions were raised to indicate or show how Analytic Philosophy figures center stage on the conceptual and linguistic analysis of key educational concepts, expressions, and their relevant meanings. These questions are: "what do you mean?"; "How do you know?"; and "What may we pre-suppose?"...
As to the first question, "What do you mean?", she offered a linguistic analysis of the educational terms: teaching; conditioning; and indoctrinating. Worth noting in her analysis is her suggestion that teaching does not necessarily overlap with the concepts represented by the terms conditioning, training, and indoctrinating. Consequently, a case of mutual exclusivity may be drawn from the concepts represented by the terms: teacher; conditioner; trainer; and indoctrinator, as used in the linguistic situation of education. This, she differentiated strongly with situational actual linguistic examples, and with the end-in-view of preserving the "discriminatory force or power" of the terms as used.
Another equally worth noting in her qualification of the term teaching is that she has linked it up with the term learning as the conscious act of knowing what ought to be done and achieved by the learner. Orteza attempted to point out in this question the need to disambiguate the employment of certain terms in particular linguistic situations for purposes of clarity and precision.
Her second question, "How do you know?", attempts to show the need for the establishment of a valid ground in reason for one's claim. And that such ground serves as basis for the truth - or the lack of it, and its acceptance or rejection.
She argued that certain situations warrant that the truth of a claim be established according to a conscious recognition of its truth by the person making the claim. Such recognition comes as an actual observation of the truth of the claim for purposes of verification. Here is when Orteza acknowledged that the desirable case in teaching is when the learner's claim is of a verified truth and whose truth is recognized as such by the learner. She termed such a mental state as "one who knows".
On her third question: "What may we pre-suppose?", she cautioned against jumping to uncalled for conclusions. she recognized that there are certain linguistic situations that make use of concepts whose truth cannot be established by empirical warrants alone. Concepts in morality for instance, necessitate that they be used with recognition of the overriding moral principles that are germane in them. In the same manner, Orteza figured that matters of belief have to be understood in the religious context from which such beliefs find a logical knowledge domain. She argued in this sense that no language is superior to any other language for each language has its intrinsic role and function. This, according to Orteza, is what differentiates Analytic Philosophy from Traditional Philosophy. She posited that, more than the accumulation of a body of philosophic knowledge, Analytic Philosophy interests itself more on the activity of philosophizing.
To illustrate her point on the place of Analytic Philosophy of education on the education and training of school teachers, she identified teaching and learning as two independent activities. Common only to both is the logical truth that they are, in her words, "try verbs". This term suggests that other than the given activities that they purport, certain extraneous circumstances may yet prove to be influential in determining whether they succeed or fail. To this end, Orteza stipulated why, conceptually, the statement, "To teach is to cause to learn" is wrong, using in its strictest sense, the term "cause".
The other aspect in Orteza's definition of "place" is the presumed function in the linguistic situation of education. Here, she considered as problems, the encounters by teachers of "so-called" practical problems. She clarified the concept of practical problems by placing it in stark contrast to theoretical problems where the nature of the case comes of foremost consideration. Practical problems as defined by Orteza are "gaps, hindrances, or discrepancies" that come in the way of people who are suppose to do what they ought to do but are caught in a bind. Orteza's treatment of practical problems goes beyond identification of the nature of the case. She suggested that in encounters with practical problem, it is more important to do something about it, get out of the bind, and go on withe the activity. More than common sense, practical problems have to be dissected into their constituent parts and be addressed with know-hows that have "logical bearing on them".
Also on the function aspect of Analytic Philosophy's place in education, Orteza raised the need for teachers to know how to justify their acts. Considering that Analytic Philosophy is a second order activity, justification has to come from concepts that are confined in the dimension of the teacher's task. Simply put, an important part of the teacher's disciplined thinking is to be clear-headed about his task.
Critique
Prof. Evelina M. Oretza made a strong point in arguing for the place of Analytic Philosophy of education in the education and training of school teachers. Most illuminating in her paper is the clarity and precision with which she defined "place" as applied to the linguistic situation of education.She appropriated the elements of role and function to her definition of "place" and proceeded to expound on them.
Orteza, in building up her case for Analytic Philosophy, detailed how detached Traditional Philosophy is in addressing practical problems of foremost significance to teachers. As such, she offered Analytic Philosophy as a more practicable method of bringing about clarity in educative linguistic situations and receptive of the manner with which practical problems are resolved. There hardly is any fault to be found here, given the propensity with which Traditional Philosophy uses traditional concepts and methods to show how a learner's experiences, if organized to approximate certain assumptions, will result in the achievement of a good life. But to say that Traditional Philosophy is concerned more in raising and addressing speculative statements about the nature of truth and reality and that there is not much to expect from it is, to an extent, jumping the gun a bit. For, is there not a certain degree of probability in which Traditional Philosophy may complement Ananlytic Philosophy? Should Traditional Philosophy be supplemented entirely by Analytic Philosophy for the latter to assert its truth?
Orteza cited for instance, one problem in Traditional Philosophy arising from the existential claim that "human nature has no nature". Whether is be a presupposition devoid of any immediate value and implication for education, it may be raised that this is just a claim out of a multitude of other claims, valid or not, that an existentialist believes or adheres in. Educationally, Existentialism, as the case is in Realism, concerns itself more on how to gear the child up to better equip him with an understanding and acceptance of the demands made upon him by the laws of nature. Or, take the educational framework from Idealism. Educationally, Idealism is ideal-centered where learners are made to reflect through their selves, the eternal understandings of an Ideal existence. These may perhaps all fall under speculative statements and belief-systems, but this after all, is what Orteza incorporated as explanation in her attempt to answer her third motivational question, "What may we presuppose?". Did she not suggest that depending upon the nature of the statement under consideration, one must caution oneself from jumping to conclusions and consider first the knowledge domain of which the presupposed claim is a legitimate part?
There is hardly any dispute to Orteza's claim that clarity and precision in language need to be upheld in all possible situations where they are deemed necessary and due. She argued quite strongly on her first question, "What do you mean?". Her vivid differentiation of the concepts of teaching, training, conditioning, and indoctrinating is most enlightening to say the least. Properly defined, she has successfully linked teaching to learning and appropriately labeled them as "try verbs" based on the uncertainty - whether that of success or failure, of their outcomes.
Perhaps the only point that needs to be raised here is whether or not, Genetics figures much on the uncertainty of teaching-learning outcomes. It must be noted that central (or, associational?) to the intrinsic capacity of a learner to process statements in a given linguistic situation is the nature of the statement in question. Does it fall in a knowledge domain of high heritability value? If so, then all that the teacher has to do is help the learner optimize his genetic potential without much intervention to stimulate the learner's inclination, which in this case is genetically predetermined.
As to the second question,"How do you know?", Orteza's most fundamental claim centers on the proposition that "one who knows" is in a mental state that is cognizant of the truth of his claim and that such truth is verified to be true indeed. She managed to bring this idea out by providing a pointillistic description of the entirety of the knowing process, considering as discriminants for the making of a strong or weak case, the conditions of truth, evidence, and beliefs.
With very little doubt, all three questions have successfully carved out a place for Analytic Philosophy of education in the education and training of school teachers. Only a few randomly germinated questions come to mind. Like, why at all must Analytic Philosophy be labeled as a second order activity? Can it not be a case of an activity preceding the task of education and completing it?
Lastly, on account of the title, can the term education not provide a knowledge domain in which the term training finds a logical bearing?
Saturday, December 16, 2006
From the Holy See
MESSAGE OF HIS HOLINESS
POPE BENEDICT XVI
FOR THE CELEBRATION OF THE
WORLD DAY OF PEACE
1 JANUARY 2007
THE HUMAN PERSON, THE HEART OF PEACE
1. At the beginning of the new year, I wish to extend prayerful good wishes for peace to Governments, leaders of nations and all men and women of good will. In a special way, I invoke peace upon all those experiencing pain and suffering, those living under the threat of violence and armed aggression, and those who await their human and social emancipation, having had their dignity trampled upon. I invoke peace upon children, who by their innocence enrich humanity with goodness and hope, and by their sufferings compel us all to work for justice and peace. Out of concern for children, especially those whose future is compromised by exploitation and the malice of unscrupulous adults, I wish on this World Day of Peace to encourage everyone to reflect on the theme: The Human Person, the Heart of Peace. I am convinced that respect for the person promotes peace and that, in building peace, the foundations are laid for an authentic integral humanism. In this way a serene future is prepared for coming generations.
The human person and peace: gift and task
2. Sacred Scripture affirms that “God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created them; male and female he created them” (Gen 1:27). As one created in the image of God, each individual human being has the dignity of a person; he or she is not just something, but someone, capable of self-knowledge, self-possession, free self-giving and entering into communion with others. At the same time, each person is called, by grace, to a covenant with the Creator, called to offer him a response of faith and love that no other creature can give in his place(1). From this supernatural perspective, one can understand the task entrusted to human beings to mature in the ability to love and to contribute to the progress of the world, renewing it in justice and in peace. In a striking synthesis, Saint Augustine teaches that “God created us without our aid; but he did not choose to save us without our aid(2).” Consequently all human beings have the duty to cultivate an awareness of this twofold aspect of gift and task.
3. Likewise, peace is both gift and task. If it is true that peace between individuals and peoples—the ability to live together and to build relationships of justice and solidarity—calls for unfailing commitment on our part, it is also true, and indeed more so, that peace is a gift from God. Peace is an aspect of God's activity, made manifest both in the creation of an orderly and harmonious universe and also in the redemption of humanity that needs to be rescued from the disorder of sin. Creation and Redemption thus provide a key that helps us begin to understand the meaning of our life on earth. My venerable predecessor Pope John Paul II, addressing the General Assembly of the United Nations on 5 October 1995, stated that “we do not live in an irrational or meaningless world... there is a moral logic which is built into human life and which makes possible dialogue between individuals and peoples(3) .” The transcendent “grammar”, that is to say the body of rules for individual action and the reciprocal relationships of persons in accordance with justice and solidarity, is inscribed on human consciences, in which the wise plan of God is reflected. As I recently had occasion to reaffirm: “we believe that at the beginning of everything is the Eternal Word, Reason and not Unreason(4).” Peace is thus also a task demanding of everyone a personal response consistent with God's plan. The criterion inspiring this response can only be respect for the “grammar” written on human hearts by the divine Creator.
From this standpoint, the norms of the natural law should not be viewed as externally imposed decrees, as restraints upon human freedom. Rather, they should be welcomed as a call to carry out faithfully the universal divine plan inscribed in the nature of human beings. Guided by these norms, all peoples —within their respective cultures—can draw near to the greatest mystery, which is the mystery of God. Today too, recognition and respect for natural law represents the foundation for a dialogue between the followers of the different religions and between believers and non-believers. As a great point of convergence, this is also a fundamental presupposition for authentic peace.
The right to life and to religious freedom
4. The duty to respect the dignity of each human being, in whose nature the image of the Creator is reflected, means in consequence that the person can not be disposed of at will. Those with greater political, technical, or economic power may not use that power to violate the rights of others who are less fortunate. Peace is based on respect for the rights of all. Conscious of this, the Church champions the fundamental rights of each person. In particular she promotes and defends respect for the life and the religious freedom of everyone. Respect for the right to life at every stage firmly establishes a principle of decisive importance: life is a gift which is not completely at the disposal of the subject. Similarly, the affirmation of the right to religious freedom places the human being in a relationship with a transcendent principle which withdraws him from human caprice. The right to life and to the free expression of personal faith in God is not subject to the power of man. Peace requires the establishment of a clear boundary between what is at man's disposal and what is not: in this way unacceptable intrusions into the patrimony of specifically human values will be avoided.
5. As far as the right to life is concerned, we must denounce its widespread violation in our society: alongside the victims of armed conflicts, terrorism and the different forms of violence, there are the silent deaths caused by hunger, abortion, experimentation on human embryos and euthanasia. How can we fail to see in all this an attack on peace? Abortion and embryonic experimentation constitute a direct denial of that attitude of acceptance of others which is indispensable for establishing lasting relationships of peace. As far as the free expression of personal faith is concerned, another disturbing symptom of lack of peace in the world is represented by the difficulties that both Christians and the followers of other religions frequently encounter in publicly and freely professing their religious convictions. Speaking of Christians in particular, I must point out with pain that not only are they at times prevented from doing so; in some States they are actually persecuted, and even recently tragic cases of ferocious violence have been recorded. There are regimes that impose a single religion upon everyone, while secular regimes often lead not so much to violent persecution as to systematic cultural denigration of religious beliefs. In both instances, a fundamental human right is not being respected, with serious repercussions for peaceful coexistence. This can only promote a mentality and culture that is not conducive to peace.
The natural equality of all persons
6. At the origin of many tensions that threaten peace are surely the many unjust inequalities still tragically present in our world. Particularly insidious among these are, on the one hand, inequality in access to essential goods like food, water, shelter, health; on the other hand, there are persistent inequalities between men and women in the exercise of basic human rights.
A fundamental element of building peace is the recognition of the essential equality of human persons springing from their common transcendental dignity. Equality on this level is a good belonging to all, inscribed in that natural “grammar” which is deducible from the divine plan of creation; it is a good that cannot be ignored or scorned without causing serious repercussions which put peace at risk. The extremely grave deprivation afflicting many peoples, especially in Africa, lies at the root of violent reactions and thus inflicts a terrible wound on peace.
7. Similarly, inadequate consideration for the condition of women helps to create instability in the fabric of society. I think of the exploitation of women who are treated as objects, and of the many ways that a lack of respect is shown for their dignity; I also think —in a different context—of the mindset persisting in some cultures, where women are still firmly subordinated to the arbitrary decisions of men, with grave consequences for their personal dignity and for the exercise of their fundamental freedoms. There can be no illusion of a secure peace until these forms of discrimination are also overcome, since they injure the personal dignity impressed by the Creator upon every human being(5).
The “ecology of peace”
8. In his Encyclical Letter Centesimus Annus, Pope John Paul II wrote: “Not only has God given the earth to man, who must use it with respect for the original good purpose for which it was given to him, but man too is God's gift to man. He must therefore respect the natural and moral structure with which he has been endowed(6).” By responding to this charge, entrusted to them by the Creator, men and women can join in bringing about a world of peace. Alongside the ecology of nature, there exists what can be called a “human” ecology, which in turn demands a “social” ecology. All this means that humanity, if it truly desires peace, must be increasingly conscious of the links between natural ecology, or respect for nature, and human ecology. Experience shows that disregard for the environment always harms human coexistence, and vice versa. It becomes more and more evident that there is an inseparable link between peace with creation and peace among men. Both of these presuppose peace with God. The poem-prayer of Saint Francis, known as “the Canticle of Brother Sun”, is a wonderful and ever timely example of this multifaceted ecology of peace.
9. The close connection between these two ecologies can be understood from the increasingly serious problem of energy supplies. In recent years, new nations have entered enthusiastically into industrial production, thereby increasing their energy needs. This has led to an unprecedented race for available resources. Meanwhile, some parts of the planet remain backward and development is effectively blocked, partly because of the rise in energy prices. What will happen to those peoples? What kind of development or non-development will be imposed on them by the scarcity of energy supplies? What injustices and conflicts will be provoked by the race for energy sources? And what will be the reaction of those who are excluded from this race? These are questions that show how respect for nature is closely linked to the need to establish, between individuals and between nations, relationships that are attentive to the dignity of the person and capable of satisfying his or her authentic needs. The destruction of the environment, its improper or selfish use, and the violent hoarding of the earth's resources cause grievances, conflicts and wars, precisely because they are the consequences of an inhumane concept of development. Indeed, if development were limited to the technical-economic aspect, obscuring the moral-religious dimension, it would not be an integral human development, but a one-sided distortion which would end up by unleashing man's destructive capacities.
Reductive visions of man
10. Thus there is an urgent need, even within the framework of current international difficulties and tensions, for a commitment to a human ecology that can favour the growth of the “tree of peace”. For this to happen, we must be guided by a vision of the person untainted by ideological and cultural prejudices or by political and economic interests which can instil hatred and violence. It is understandable that visions of man will vary from culture to culture. Yet what cannot be admitted is the cultivation of anthropological conceptions that contain the seeds of hostility and violence. Equally unacceptable are conceptions of God that would encourage intolerance and recourse to violence against others. This is a point which must be clearly reaffirmed: war in God's name is never acceptable! When a certain notion of God is at the origin of criminal acts, it is a sign that that notion has already become an ideology.
11. Today, however, peace is not only threatened by the conflict between reductive visions of man, in other words, between ideologies. It is also threatened by indifference as to what constitutes man's true nature. Many of our contemporaries actually deny the existence of a specific human nature and thus open the door to the most extravagant interpretations of what essentially constitutes a human being. Here too clarity is necessary: a “weak” vision of the person, which would leave room for every conception, even the most bizarre, only apparently favours peace. In reality, it hinders authentic dialogue and opens the way to authoritarian impositions, ultimately leaving the person defenceless and, as a result, easy prey to oppression and violence.
Human rights and international organizations
12. A true and stable peace presupposes respect for human rights. Yet if these rights are grounded on a weak conception of the person, how can they fail to be themselves weakened? Here we can see how profoundly insufficient is a relativistic conception of the person when it comes to justifying and defending his rights. The difficulty in this case is clear: rights are proposed as absolute, yet the foundation on which they are supposed to rest is merely relative. Can we wonder that, faced with the “inconvenient” demands posed by one right or another, someone will come along to question it or determine that it should be set aside? Only if they are grounded in the objective requirements of the nature bestowed on man by the Creator, can the rights attributed to him be affirmed without fear of contradiction. It goes without saying, moreover, that human rights imply corresponding duties. In this regard, Mahatma Gandhi said wisely: “The Ganges of rights flows from the Himalaya of duties.” Clarity over these basic presuppositions is needed if human rights, nowadays constantly under attack, are to be adequately defended. Without such clarity, the expression “human rights” will end up being predicated of quite different subjects: in some cases, the human person marked by permanent dignity and rights that are valid always, everywhere and for everyone, in other cases a person with changing dignity and constantly negotiable rights, with regard to content, time and place.
13. The protection of human rights is constantly referred to by international bodies and, in particular, the United Nations Organization, which set itself the fundamental task of promoting the human rights indicated in the 1948 Universal Declaration. That Declaration is regarded as a sort of moral commitment assumed by all mankind. There is a profound truth to this, especially if the rights described in the Declaration are held to be based not simply on the decisions of the assembly that approved them, but on man's very nature and his inalienable dignity as a person created by God. Consequently it is important for international agencies not to lose sight of the natural foundation of human rights. This would enable them to avoid the risk, unfortunately ever-present, of sliding towards a merely positivistic interpretation of those rights. Were that to happen, the international bodies would end up lacking the necessary authority to carry out their role as defenders of the fundamental rights of the person and of peoples, the chief justification for their very existence and activity.
International humanitarian law and the internal law of States
14. The recognition that there exist inalienable human rights connected to our common human nature has led to the establishment of a body of international humanitarian law which States are committed to respect, even in the case of war. Unfortunately, to say nothing of past cases, this has not been consistently implemented in certain recent situations of war. Such, for example, was the case in the conflict that occurred a few months ago in southern Lebanon, where the duty “to protect and help innocent victims” and to avoid involving the civilian population was largely ignored. The heart-rending situation in Lebanon and the new shape of conflicts, especially since the terrorist threat unleashed completely new forms of violence, demand that the international community reaffirm international humanitarian law, and apply it to all present-day situations of armed conflict, including those not currently provided for by international law. Moreover, the scourge of terrorism demands a profound reflection on the ethical limits restricting the use of modern methods of guaranteeing internal security. Increasingly, wars are not declared, especially when they are initiated by terrorist groups determined to attain their ends by any means available. In the face of the disturbing events of recent years, States cannot fail to recognize the need to establish clearer rules to counter effectively the dramatic decline that we are witnessing. War always represents a failure for the international community and a grave loss for humanity. When, despite every effort, war does break out, at least the essential principles of humanity and the basic values of all civil coexistence must be safeguarded; norms of conduct must be established that limit the damage as far as possible and help to alleviate the suffering of civilians and of all the victims of conflicts(7).
15. Another disturbing issue is the desire recently shown by some States to acquire nuclear weapons. This has heightened even more the widespread climate of uncertainty and fear of a possible atomic catastrophe. We are brought back in time to the profound anxieties of the “cold war” period. When it came to an end, there was hope that the atomic peril had been definitively overcome and that mankind could finally breathe a lasting sigh of relief. How timely, in this regard, is the warning of the Second Vatican Council that “every act of war directed to the indiscriminate destruction of whole cities or vast areas with their inhabitants is a crime against God and humanity, which merits firm and unequivocal condemnation(8).” Unfortunately, threatening clouds continue to gather on humanity's horizon. The way to ensure a future of peace for everyone is found not only in international accords for the non-proliferation of nuclear weapons, but also in the determined commitment to seek their reduction and definitive dismantling. May every attempt be made to arrive through negotiation at the attainment of these objectives! The fate of the whole human family is at stake!
The Church as safeguard of the transcendence of the human person
16. Finally, I wish to make an urgent appeal to the People of God: let every Christian be committed to tireless peace-making and strenuous defence of the dignity of the human person and his inalienable rights.
With gratitude to the Lord for having called him to belong to his Church, which is “the sign and safeguard of the transcendental dimension of the human person”(9) in the world, the Christian will tirelessly implore from God the fundamental good of peace, which is of such primary importance in the life of each person. Moreover, he will be proud to serve the cause of peace with generous devotion, offering help to his brothers and sisters, especially those who, in addition to suffering poverty and need, are also deprived of this precious good. Jesus has revealed to us that “God is love” (1 Jn 4:8) and that the highest vocation of every person is love. In Christ we can find the ultimate reason for becoming staunch champions of human dignity and courageous builders of peace.
17. Let every believer, then, unfailingly contribute to the advancement of a true integral humanism in accordance with the teachings of the Encyclical Letters Populorum Progressio and Sollicitudo Rei Socialis, whose respective fortieth and twentieth anniversaries we prepare to celebrate this year. To the Queen of Peace, the Mother of Jesus Christ “our peace” (Eph 2:14), I entrust my urgent prayer for all humanity at the beginning of the year 2007, to which we look with hearts full of hope, notwithstanding the dangers and difficulties that surround us. May Mary show us, in her Son, the Way of peace, and enlighten our vision, so that we can recognize Christ's face in the face of every human person, the heart of peace!
From the Vatican, 8 December 2006.
Wednesday, December 13, 2006
Ch. 1 of my Research Proposal
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
A. Background of the Study
"If a single word had to be chosen to describe the goals of science educators
during the 30-year period that began in the late 1950s, it would have to be
INQUIRY." (DeBoer, 1991, p. 206).
The Inquiry-based approach to teaching science seeks to engage the student in the investigative nature of science. Using this approach, more emphases are placed on the process of gathering information, converting data to scientific knowledge, and using scientific knowledge in the resolution of problems. In an article by Haury entitled, ‘Teaching Science Through Inquiry’ published in 1993, he observed that “some have emphasized the active nature of student involvement, associating inquiry with ‘hands-on’ learning and experiential or activity-based instruction. Others have linked inquiry with a discovery approach or with development of process skills associated with ‘the scientific method.’ Though these various concepts are interrelated, inquiry-oriented instruction is not synonymous with any of them.” In essence, what this approach does is to make the student an active participant in his or her education by learning science the way science is done.
The inquiry-based approach to teaching science takes on a new dimension though, when confined within the framework of a Transformative Science Curriculum like the curriculum adopted at Berea Arts and Sciences High School. In a dissertation proposal that Mr. Aurelio Ramos - the President of BASHS - wrote in 2005, he qualified the Berea Transformative Curriculum as one that “is centered on the learner and has three areas of concentration: Knowledge, character, and service. Transformation occurs as the individual learner moves from where he is – brought there by the level of knowledge acquired in grade school, the qualities and behavior developed in childhood, and the orientation to service (whether or not this exists) learned in his social environment – to where he has the potential to be. In all three areas, education is holistic. Thus, the curriculum content stimulates both analytic (left) and global (right) parts of the brain; values training is incorporated in all subjects; and service becomes a curricular as against wholly an extra curricular part of the academic program.”
The idea behind the integration of an inquiry-based approach to teaching science in the
As both the Inquiry-Based Approach to teaching science and the
Model of Transformative Science Curriculum are recognizably multifaceted and
differently situated, it is considered that inquiry in this regard, which is taken as
an attempt to carry out the teaching of science in a manner with which it is
practiced through the scientific method, may take on a different dimension when
confined in the Transformative Science Curriculum. Thus considered, can the
Inquiry-Based Approach to teaching science - which saw widespread
implementation in the early ‘90s - be implemented and applied to the Berean
experience and still touch on the constructivist models of learning, complemented
to varying degrees by project-based teaching and problem-based instruction?
The key questions subsumed in this proposal are: (1) how can Inquiry-Based
Approach to science teaching be implemented in the framework of a
Transformative Curriculum in Science? (2) what are possible implications that
may arise from its implementation? and (3) how can Inquiry-Based Approach to
teaching science using the Transformative Curriculum translate more effectively
to scientific knowledge?
During the 1990s, a number of science education initiatives were undertaken to
reform high school science teaching to reflect strategies from the latest research and to enable more students to attain a higher level of scientific literacy. (Dean
Goodwin, 1996).
Science can be taught in a wide range of settings, from a regular classroom to a state-of-the-art facility dedicated to science instruction. All of these learning environments, though, should have several common features to facilitate quality science instruction. (Dan Butin, July 2000).
At PSHS, where Science is taught taking into consideration both depth and breadth, laboratory exercises play central role in the educative process and are complemented only by lectures or facilitations. At PSHS, Dewey’s Pragmatist approach defines, for the most part, the teaching of science. And there is no question as to its efficacy on the basis of student achievement. At Berea Arts and
BASHS is only on its second year of operation. As it is a new school - and the
first of its kind in the country, we are still in the initial stages of conceptualizing
what features – in terms of special course offerings, are necessary to beef up our
curriculum with and with the end-in-view of improving student achievement within
the framework of a Transformative curriculum.
In this proposal, the idea of studying the implications of confining the teaching of science within a Transformative curriculum on student achievement is considered. The idea behind this proposal is that while right-brained students are achieving well in schools for the arts like the Philippine High School for the Arts and that the same level of achievement is noted with left-brained students who are enrolled in science schools like the PSHS, can holistic education for either left-brained or right-brained students, like that being offered at BASHS approximate the same or higher level of achievement?
B. Statement of the Problem
This study seeks to determine whether integrating an inquiry-based approach to teaching transformative science improve the performance of students. Also, this study aims to provide an insight into possible avenues of effectively implementing transformative science and enriching the curriculum. To which end, the following questions are considered: (1) how can Inquiry-Based Approach to science teaching be implemented in the framework of a Transformative Curriculum in Science? (2) what are possible implications that may arise from its implementation? and (3) how can Inquiry-Based Approach to teaching science using the Transformative Curriculum translate more effectively to scientific knowledge?
C. Significance of the Study
If the study is able to show that the integration of an inquiry-based approach to the teaching of science in a transformative curriculum framework results to a significantly higher student achievement and better performance, then new insights may be reintroduced to refine the transformative curriculum of Berea and make it more responsive to the needs of students who are endowed with both logical and global inclinations.
If proved that inquiry-based approach to teaching science is able to complement the Berean transformative curriculum, then students will be benefited hugely first, for the transformation that the curriculum seeks to equip them with in preparation for college life.
D. Scope and Delimitations of the Study
This proposed study touches only on the relationship between an inquiry-based approach to teaching science and the
Monday, December 11, 2006
Atypical Berea
Thursday, December 07, 2006
Theory of Nullity
My Research Proposal
RESEARCH PROPOSAL (An Overview)
Michael Anthony B. Mantala
Educ 293 - December 5, 2005
"If a single word had to be chosen to describe the goals of science educators during the 30-year period that began in the late 1950s, it would have to be INQUIRY." (DeBoer, 1991, p. 206).
This research proposal centers on the area of Inquiry-Based Approach to teaching science. This is an approach that seeks to engage the student in the investigative nature of science. Emphasis using this approach is placed more on the process of gathering information, converting data to scientific knowledge, and using scientific knowledge in the resolution of problems. In essence, what this approach does is to make the student an active participant in his or her education by learning science the way science is done. It takes on a new wind though, when confined within the framework of a Transformative Science Curriculum like that adopted at Berea Arts and
As both the Inquiry-Based Approach to teaching science and the Berea Model of Transformative Science Curriculum are recognizably multifaceted and differently situated, it is considered that inquiry in this regard, which is taken as an attempt to carry out the teaching of science in a manner with which it is practiced through the scientific method, may take on a different dimension when confined in the Transformative Science Curriculum. Thus considered, can the Inquiry-Based Approach to teaching science - which saw widespread implementation in the early ‘90s - be implemented and applied to the Berean experience and still touch on the constructivist models of learning, complemented to varying degrees by project-based teaching and problem-based instruction?
The key questions subsumed in this proposal are: (1) how can Inquiry-Based Approach to science teaching be implemented in the framework of a Transformative Curriculum in Science? (2) what are possible implications that may arise from its implementation? and (3) how can Inquiry-Based Approach to teaching science using the Transformative Curriculum translate more effectively to scientific knowledge?
The House of Con-Ass's
Thursday, October 12, 2006
Air Pollution and Chemistry Notes
Thursday, October 05, 2006
Air Pollution
Wednesday, October 04, 2006
Nobel Prize Announcements
Tuesday, October 03, 2006
Notice
Hi kids and littluns... What do you think about today's suspension of classes?
Sunday, October 01, 2006
The Miracle Of Science
Notice
Pls. be reminded that your next LTs are scheduled on the week of October 9... Do start studying...
Wednesday, September 27, 2006
Stem Cell Debate
Covalent and Ionic Bonds
Covalent and Ionic Bonds Problem Set
Notes
Ionic bond – a strong attractive force holding ions together. An ionic bond can
form between two atoms by the transfer of electrons from the valence shell of one atom to the valence shell of the other
Covalent bond – a strong attractive force that holds two atoms together by their
sharing of electrons. These bonding electrons are attracted simultaneously to both atomic nuclei, and they spend part of the time near one atom and part of the time near the other
Electronegativities – the unequal abilities of the atoms to draw bonding electrons
to themselves
Lewis electron-dot formulas – simple representations of the valence-shell
electrons of atoms in molecules and ions and are useful for describing the covalent bonding in substances
Problem Set.
1. For each of the following pairs of elements, state whether the binary compound formed is likely to be ionic or covalent. Give the formula and name of the compound.
a. Sr,O b. C,Br c. Ga, F d. N, Br
2. Give the Lewis formula for the arsenate ion, AsO3-4. Write the formula of lead(II) arsenate.
3. Iodic acid, HIO3, is a colorless, crystalline compound. What is the electron dot formula of iodic acid?
4. Write electron dot formulas for the following:
a. SeOCl2 b. CSe2 c. GaCl-4 d. C2-2
5. Why do most monoatomic cations of the main-group elements have a charge equal to the group number? Why do most monoatomic anions of these elements have a charge equal to the group number minus 8?
6. Describe the formation of a covalent bond in H2 from atoms. What does it mean to say that the bonding electrons are shared by the two atoms?
